Guthrie Twist, Human Remains Found, and Facebook Marketplace Murder Investigations

By Craig Chapman, Desiree Edwards, and Tanisha Slater. Tonight, we unpack three massive true crime stories. First, a shocking twist in the Nancy Guthrie timeline reveals secret investigator notes. Next, we analyze the Brian Cohee Jr. case featured on A&E’s newly renewed "Crime in Progress." Finally, we debate the murder of Joshua Swink, who was fatally shot over a counterfeit money Facebook Marketplace deal. Who is at fault for the escalation? What are your theories?